The ghostly graves of Killingworth, Connecticut
Nov 06, 2026 09:55AM ● By Thomas D’AgostinoThe story of a grave where nothing will grow over it is not uncommon. Almost every state has some sort of legend or tale regarding barren grave sites where grass or lichen refuses to sprout. This account would certainly give good reason why the tale of the bare graves of Union District Cemetery on North Roast Meat Hill Road would harbor natural covering.
Sarah Blatchley (August 31, 1746, to October, 1779) and Samuel Higgins were married on November 9, 1769. They moved to an old cottage on what is now Wolf Hill Road. The couple had five children between 1771 and 1779. Sarah was a bit outspoken with a quick and violent temper, yet Samuel (born December 19, 1742, and died June 30, 1811) was very patient with her sudden rages.
This went on for several years until October 14, 1779, when Samuel came home to see the most shocking sight. Three of his young children were slain by Sarah and she was about to take her own life by slitting her throat with a dull knife. Samuel came in just in time to stop her.
A newspaper account from the Boston Evening Post and General Advertiser October 30, 1779, tells much of the story.
“The following tragic affair happened at the North Parish in Killingworth on Wednesday last, viz. The wife of Samuel Higgins of that parish, being disordered in her reason, and being left in the house with three of her children, she called the son of seven years old to her, telling him she wanted to pin his collar, and immediately cut his throat, she then cut the throats of her daughter five years old, and her infant which lay on the bed…”
William age 7, Sarah, age 5 and Jane, just 2 months old at the time, were buried in the Union Cemetery with simple stones, as the cost of more elaborate markers were at the time beyond the financial reach of the Higgins. Samuel went on to marry Temperence Parkhill Kelsey in 1781. They moved to Benson, Vermont where they lived out the rest of their lives. The other two Higgins children, Martha and Reuben lived to a ripe old age before passing on to the world of spirits.
Legends abound in regard to Mrs. Higgins living out the rest of her life repenting her sin. Oddly enough, she was never prosecuted for her crime. She waited in hopes of her husband to return and provide her with three more children. One account, as written in J.H. Beers, The History of Middlesex County is presented below:
“About a mile and a half north of the Congregational church, in Killingworth, on the old road which runs parallel with the main street, is a group of dilapidated houses. In one of these ancient dwellings there formerly lived a Mrs. Higgins, who was possessed of a most violent temper. October 14th, 1779, after having quarreled with her husband, she grasped a common case- knife and cut the throats of her three children. The victims of this bloody tragedy were buried in the old cemetery, in the Union District. There was at that time a belief almost universally indulged in that grass would not grow over the grave of a murdered person; and it is said that for a long time the lot where they laid these children was barren as a desert. The natural sterility of the soil, however, is a sufficient explanation of the phenomenon. Mrs. Higgins subsequently resided in the Pine Orchard District, near the Union Church. On that edifice there was a clock dial with stationary hands, and she was heard to say: “ When those pointers come together and stand at twelve, my sins will be pardoned.” She also cherished the strange hope that her husband, who was separated from her would return, and that she would again be the mother of three children in place of her dead offspring. She is reported to have made an attempt on her own life at the time of killing her children, but was prevented by her husband, and in after years always wore a black ribbon about her neck to cover the ugly trace of her savage rage. The story of her terrible deed was versified by a local poet, and within the memory of the living the aged women have been heard to sing in a mournful minor the sad song of this unfortunate woman. She was doubtless buried in the old cemetery in Pine Orchard District, but her grave, like that of her children, is still unlettered, and the historian looks in vain for the last resting place of her whom in charity he fain would call a maniac, not a murderer.” W
